Home
Publications
Search
Register
Log inAnanya Vajpeyi: Hindutva is a historic and ultimately doomed attempt to change Hinduism
Page 1 of 1
Ananya Vajpeyi: Hindutva is a historic and ultimately doomed attempt to change Hinduism
by Guest Sat Jul 12, 2014 5:17 pm
The problem with Hindutva
The problem with Hindutva, which has impeded its capture of the average Hindu’s political and cultural imagination, is that it is the outcome not so much of hatred for others, especially Muslims, but rather of Hindu self-hate. It’s a historic and possibly doomed attempt to change everything about Hinduism that makes it what it is — its ability to accommodate mind-boggling diversity, its avoidance of strict definitions and boundaries, its amorphous, heterogeneous, tolerant and fluid character.
Hindutva wants to “Semitize” Hinduism, giving it a god, a book, a revelation, a prophet, an ecclesiastical order, a pontiff, a race, a language, a country (or a holy land), a history, a canon, doctrinal stability and missionary zeal. It’s an attempt to standardise, essentialise, codify and systematise a vast universe of incommensurate beliefs, practices, rituals, theologies and narratives — to render Hinduism modern and modular....
If Hinduism is centrifugal, Hindutva is centripetal. Savarkar responded to the demands and pressures of modern nationalism — he was not only disinterested in, but perhaps even averse to, the religious life of millions of Hindus. It’s interesting and entirely reasonable that Savarkar was a thorough atheist. For him, being a Hindu was a political identity, not an identity based on religion. Even Muslims, Christians, Sikhs and Buddhists, so long as they are born and raised in India, and follow the Indian way of life, are thus de facto “Hindus.” Hindutva is a pure construct, a completely empty envelope that Savarkar creates from his own mind as he spends decades locked away, utterly segregated from the shared collective life of his fellow-Indians.
http://www.thehindu.com/opinion/lead/hind-swaraj-vs-hindu-rashtra/article6201620.ece?homepage=true
The problem with Hindutva, which has impeded its capture of the average Hindu’s political and cultural imagination, is that it is the outcome not so much of hatred for others, especially Muslims, but rather of Hindu self-hate. It’s a historic and possibly doomed attempt to change everything about Hinduism that makes it what it is — its ability to accommodate mind-boggling diversity, its avoidance of strict definitions and boundaries, its amorphous, heterogeneous, tolerant and fluid character.
Hindutva wants to “Semitize” Hinduism, giving it a god, a book, a revelation, a prophet, an ecclesiastical order, a pontiff, a race, a language, a country (or a holy land), a history, a canon, doctrinal stability and missionary zeal. It’s an attempt to standardise, essentialise, codify and systematise a vast universe of incommensurate beliefs, practices, rituals, theologies and narratives — to render Hinduism modern and modular....
If Hinduism is centrifugal, Hindutva is centripetal. Savarkar responded to the demands and pressures of modern nationalism — he was not only disinterested in, but perhaps even averse to, the religious life of millions of Hindus. It’s interesting and entirely reasonable that Savarkar was a thorough atheist. For him, being a Hindu was a political identity, not an identity based on religion. Even Muslims, Christians, Sikhs and Buddhists, so long as they are born and raised in India, and follow the Indian way of life, are thus de facto “Hindus.” Hindutva is a pure construct, a completely empty envelope that Savarkar creates from his own mind as he spends decades locked away, utterly segregated from the shared collective life of his fellow-Indians.
http://www.thehindu.com/opinion/lead/hind-swaraj-vs-hindu-rashtra/article6201620.ece?homepage=true
Guest- Guest
Similar topics» "Dismantling Global Hindutva: A thinly veiled attempt to dismantle Hinduism" (Suhag Shukla: Firstpost - Aug 25, 2021)
» Eminent Poet Ashok Vajpeyi: I don't know how RSS will harm Islam, but it will certainly destroy Hinduism
» How the Hindutva Chaddis are destroying Hinduism from within
» Nayantara Sahgal: Hindutva is distorting Hinduism
» Chaddi initiative: "Hinduism and Hindutva will now be protected by an army of online warriors"
» Eminent Poet Ashok Vajpeyi: I don't know how RSS will harm Islam, but it will certainly destroy Hinduism
» How the Hindutva Chaddis are destroying Hinduism from within
» Nayantara Sahgal: Hindutva is distorting Hinduism
» Chaddi initiative: "Hinduism and Hindutva will now be protected by an army of online warriors"
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum