This is a Hitskin.com skin preview
Install the skin • Return to the skin page
Seva: Koenraad Elst says proceed slowly on UCC
2 posters
Page 1 of 1
Seva: Koenraad Elst says proceed slowly on UCC
All kinds of pampletteers are climbing out of the woodwork to call for policies which amount to banging your head against the wall. For instance, some say "bring an anti-conversion bill". Such a bill will do nothing at all to stop conversions (fact: in China, the Christian mission is very illegal yet very very successful), but it will provide a strong weapon to the enemies of Hinduism. If you are a mission agent, or if you are a mouse-clicking internet Hindu out to vent his emotions, then do call for an anti-conversion bill: it will hurt Modi's and Hinduism's reputation and speed up conversions. But if you are in it for Hindu victory, then proceed more intelligently.
Similarly, some people propose to make use of the unexpected parliamentary majority to implement a Common Civil Code, abolishing the present anti-secular system of religion-based Civil Codes, most prominently the Shari'a (Islamic law) for the Muslim community. This is desirable in the long term, and it is secular par excellence, for by definition, secular states have equality before the klaw of all citizens regardless of their religion. But getting there is difficult. Islamic preachers all over India will call for resistance, as this is an attack on the heart of Islam (which sees itself as a total system: theologgy, politics and the law are intimately related). Large-scale riots will follow, and the media are more than ever ready to pin the blame on the Hindus.
Moreover, this is not an issue that Hindus lose any sleep over: premodern Hindu society had different laws and customs for different Hindu communities (e.g. the alleged "Hindu" custom of widows' self-immolation was confined to the Rajput and allied castes and shunned by most Hindu castes) and naturally extended this legal pluralism to foreign communities with yet different law systems. A Common Civil Code is not a Hindu but a secular demand, and Hindus should not take the blame for the fall-out of what ought to be a reform by the secularists. So, do embark on a course leading to a ommon Civil Code, but proceed slowly and carefully. Among other things, convince the secularists that this should be their own baby, and that it is up to them to sway Muslim public opinion in favour of a modern law system.
http://koenraadelst.blogspot.com/2014/05/what-not-to-do-for-brandnew-hindu.html
Similarly, some people propose to make use of the unexpected parliamentary majority to implement a Common Civil Code, abolishing the present anti-secular system of religion-based Civil Codes, most prominently the Shari'a (Islamic law) for the Muslim community. This is desirable in the long term, and it is secular par excellence, for by definition, secular states have equality before the klaw of all citizens regardless of their religion. But getting there is difficult. Islamic preachers all over India will call for resistance, as this is an attack on the heart of Islam (which sees itself as a total system: theologgy, politics and the law are intimately related). Large-scale riots will follow, and the media are more than ever ready to pin the blame on the Hindus.
Moreover, this is not an issue that Hindus lose any sleep over: premodern Hindu society had different laws and customs for different Hindu communities (e.g. the alleged "Hindu" custom of widows' self-immolation was confined to the Rajput and allied castes and shunned by most Hindu castes) and naturally extended this legal pluralism to foreign communities with yet different law systems. A Common Civil Code is not a Hindu but a secular demand, and Hindus should not take the blame for the fall-out of what ought to be a reform by the secularists. So, do embark on a course leading to a ommon Civil Code, but proceed slowly and carefully. Among other things, convince the secularists that this should be their own baby, and that it is up to them to sway Muslim public opinion in favour of a modern law system.
http://koenraadelst.blogspot.com/2014/05/what-not-to-do-for-brandnew-hindu.html
Rishi- Posts : 5129
Join date : 2011-09-02
Re: Seva: Koenraad Elst says proceed slowly on UCC
His is a moronic suggestion -- don't listen to him.
Re: Seva: Koenraad Elst says proceed slowly on UCC
I once saw a Muslim woman (a social worker) during a panel discussion on the TV pleading that Govt. should pass a law against the wearing of burqa by women.
An elderly bearded man, also on the same panel discussion and not even a Muslim himself, countered the woman’s statement, saying “Muslim women should enjoy the freedom to wear burqa without any interference or law from Govt.”
I said to myself, “either this guy has his head stuck in shit or he can’t stand the idea of Muslim women making progress.”
An elderly bearded man, also on the same panel discussion and not even a Muslim himself, countered the woman’s statement, saying “Muslim women should enjoy the freedom to wear burqa without any interference or law from Govt.”
I said to myself, “either this guy has his head stuck in shit or he can’t stand the idea of Muslim women making progress.”
Similar topics
» WHy should we listen to this white guy but not Koenraad Elst?
» Devyani Khobragade case: US to proceed with her prosecution, no question of apology, say sources
» Slowly
» MSM is slowly catching up on reporting...
» you start dying slowly
» Devyani Khobragade case: US to proceed with her prosecution, no question of apology, say sources
» Slowly
» MSM is slowly catching up on reporting...
» you start dying slowly
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum