This is a Hitskin.com skin preview
Install the skin • Return to the skin page
for all the madrasis here
3 posters
Page 1 of 1
Re: for all the madrasis here
on photograph 1, the statue of thomas munro:
a small but critical part of the statue is, and has always been missing. I know that to be true from seeing the statue, not from this photograph.
question: what is that missing part?
note: an apocryphal story has it that the sculptor - I don't know his name - who accidentally omitted that part, killed himself when the omission was pointed put to him.
a small but critical part of the statue is, and has always been missing. I know that to be true from seeing the statue, not from this photograph.
question: what is that missing part?
note: an apocryphal story has it that the sculptor - I don't know his name - who accidentally omitted that part, killed himself when the omission was pointed put to him.
swapna- Posts : 1951
Join date : 2013-11-27
Re: for all the madrasis here
correction: "pointed out" not "pointed put."swapna wrote:on photograph 1, the statue of thomas munro:
a small but critical part of the statue is, and has always been missing. I know that to be true from seeing the statue, not from this photograph.
question: what is that missing part?
note: an apocryphal story has it that the sculptor - I don't know his name - who accidentally omitted that part, killed himself when the omission was pointed put to him.
swapna- Posts : 1951
Join date : 2013-11-27
Re: for all the madrasis here
swapna wrote:on photograph 1, the statue of thomas munro:
a small but critical part of the statue is, and has always been missing. I know that to be true from seeing the statue, not from this photograph.
question: what is that missing part?
note: an apocryphal story has it that the sculptor - I don't know his name - who accidentally omitted that part, killed himself when the omission was pointed put to him.
.....Nice story here. Stirrups missing?...The sculptor name is Chantrey...
Needless to say...I did not use Google...or Wiki...or any net source..
Marathadi-Saamiyaar- Posts : 17675
Join date : 2011-04-30
Age : 110
Re: for all the madrasis here
Today's Gooty and the Fort, where Munro died. I am sure he would be very PROUD of this place.
Marathadi-Saamiyaar- Posts : 17675
Join date : 2011-04-30
Age : 110
Re: for all the madrasis here
The ancestors of my paternal grandmother hail from there.Marathadi-Saamiyaar wrote:
Today's Gooty and the Fort, where Munro died. I am sure he would be very PROUD of this place.
Guest- Guest
Re: for all the madrasis here
a 2010 article that appeared in The Hindu, on thomas munro:
m.thehindu.com/features/magazine/unsung-hero-of-madras/article534676.ece
he was not the conventional colonial administrator.
m.thehindu.com/features/magazine/unsung-hero-of-madras/article534676.ece
he was not the conventional colonial administrator.
swapna- Posts : 1951
Join date : 2013-11-27
Re: for all the madrasis here
swapna wrote:a 2010 article that appeared in The Hindu, on thomas munro:
m.thehindu.com/features/magazine/unsung-hero-of-madras/article534676.ece
he was not the conventional colonial administrator.
I dont like replacing English names with Indian names - who are hardly recognizable by most Madrasis (Indians). All these names give a sense of the city history and into its past. Replacing the names cuts off that link.
There are numerous new developments, bridges, flyovers that can be named after numerous post-independent personalities (Instead of naming every structure after Anna, RG, Indira, and MK/JJ in the future.)
In any case, even the new generations still call these renamed roads by old names. Still most call Mount Road, Beach Road, Cathedral, Pycroft, Eldams, Coats, White town, Georgetown and Black town
P.S. Lord Rippon in the early 20th century is another such revered British personlity - wonder when Rippon building (Madras Corporation/council location) will be renamed. Perhaps, waiting for MK to croak.
Marathadi-Saamiyaar- Posts : 17675
Join date : 2011-04-30
Age : 110
Re: for all the madrasis here
Marathadi-Saamiyaar wrote:swapna wrote:a 2010 article that appeared in The Hindu, on thomas munro:
m.thehindu.com/features/magazine/unsung-hero-of-madras/article534676.ece
he was not the conventional colonial administrator.
I dont like replacing English names with Indian names - who are hardly recognizable by most Madrasis (Indians). All these names give a sense of the city history and into its past. Replacing the names cuts off that link.
There are numerous new developments, bridges, flyovers that can be named after numerous post-independent personalities (Instead of naming every structure after Anna, RG, Indira, and MK/JJ in the future.)
In any case, even the new generations still call these renamed roads by old names. Still most call Mount Road, Beach Road, Cathedral, Pycroft, Eldams, Coats, White town, Georgetown and Black town
P.S. Lord Rippon in the early 20th century is another such revered British personlity - wonder when Rippon building (Madras Corporation/council location) will be renamed. Perhaps, waiting for MK to croak.
actually, you seem to belong to a small minority that appears, not necessarily to revel but continue to muse about the colonial past through association with these names, statues, buildings etc., while the majority attempts to erase the haunting memories and that part of the history.
garam_kuta- Posts : 3768
Join date : 2011-05-18
Re: for all the madrasis here
garam_kuta wrote:Marathadi-Saamiyaar wrote:swapna wrote:a 2010 article that appeared in The Hindu, on thomas munro:
m.thehindu.com/features/magazine/unsung-hero-of-madras/article534676.ece
he was not the conventional colonial administrator.
I dont like replacing English names with Indian names - who are hardly recognizable by most Madrasis (Indians). All these names give a sense of the city history and into its past. Replacing the names cuts off that link.
There are numerous new developments, bridges, flyovers that can be named after numerous post-independent personalities (Instead of naming every structure after Anna, RG, Indira, and MK/JJ in the future.)
In any case, even the new generations still call these renamed roads by old names. Still most call Mount Road, Beach Road, Cathedral, Pycroft, Eldams, Coats, White town, Georgetown and Black town
P.S. Lord Rippon in the early 20th century is another such revered British personlity - wonder when Rippon building (Madras Corporation/council location) will be renamed. Perhaps, waiting for MK to croak.
actually, you seem to belong to a small minority that appears, not necessarily to revel but continue to muse about the colonial past through association with these names, statues, buildings etc., while the majority attempts to erase the haunting memories and that part of the history.
Of course...smart, sensible, and straightforward people always form a small minority.
How many madrasis know the history of the replaced "names?"
I am not saying not to name after Indian super stalwarts. We dont have enough and that is why ppl keep using the same half-dozen names over and over. Unfortunately, caste also comes into play - so no more colonies named after Rajaji, Satyamurthy, etc.
If names like Munro and Rippon are replaced - then the Tamils should not claim to be grateful and open-minded people. These are guys who spent almost their entire adult life serving Indian and Indian people without indulging in killing or opposing Indians. After all, these guys served India even before the Independence movement.
BTW, how many people - you think - know the names of the founders of Congress. More people will say Gandhi or Sonia Gandhi than identifying the real founders. Should we also drop the name of Anne Besant? Why do we still have Besant Nagar ?
Marathadi-Saamiyaar- Posts : 17675
Join date : 2011-04-30
Age : 110
Similar topics
» Only for Madrasis
» dem madrasis so virtuous
» Why do Madrasis vote for Filmi Leaders?
» Learn Hindi, you stupid Madrasis, if you want jobs
» dem madrasis so virtuous
» Why do Madrasis vote for Filmi Leaders?
» Learn Hindi, you stupid Madrasis, if you want jobs
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum