Hitskin.comThis is a Hitskin.com skin preview
Install the skin • Return to the skin page
Home
Latest imagesHow some human beings are elevated to prophetdom
Page 1 of 1
How some human beings are elevated to prophetdom
by MulaiAzhagi Sat May 12, 2012 7:36 pm
Dalit writer Kancha Ilaiah– who usually makes it a point to provoke caste war at the drop of a hat – made the same point. “Ambedkar is to Dalits what the prophet is to Muslims. He should not be seen only as a constitution-maker, which the authors of the textbook seem to have presented him as; he is fast acquiring the status of prophet for the scheduled castes of the country,” The Indian Express quoted him as saying.
Yes, he’s right. The conditions for converting Ambedkar from just an extraordinary human being and social reformer to prophet seem just right.
Several conditions must exist for a social or political icon to be elevated to the status of near-god or prophet. Four, in particular, are important.
First, the political conditions must be right. There must be sufficiently large numbers that feel excluded and are in search of the right way to empower themselves.
Second, the sense of alienation from the dominant culture must be acute and widely felt across the community. If the dominant culture somehow conveys the impression of superiority, the task of elevating a leader to saint becomes easier.
Third, the dominant culture should be in decline and seized with self-doubt.
Fourth, elevation to prophethood does not depend on what the prophet may actually have said or done; it depends on the will of his followers and their need for political power.
Let’s consider the historical precedents first. Buddha and Mahavira emerged as non-theistic icons and prophets when overweening Brahminism was creating a social decline and sense of disgust in the broader population.
The elevation of Jesus Christ to Son of God happened centuries after the crucifixion and that, too, not among the people he was born – the Jews, where he would merely have been a social reformer. Jesus became messiah first in Europe, where the decline of Roman values was becoming apparent and anti-Semitism was rising as a political mood.
The rise of the prophet of Islam happened in the context where both Jews and Christians claimed to be people of the book, and hence superior. They looked down on the tribal Arabs as uncultured and uncivilised. Mohammed emerged as a prophet in this backdrop.
A counter-point can be made with Gandhi. As moral leaders go, Gandhi would have been considered a prophet or saint equivalent to a Jesus or Mohammed in any other era but the 20th century. But the 20th century was the era of rising rationalism, where saints had to be reduced to ordinary mortals. The demythification of Gandhi has begun in the west, and will continue.
So why should it be any different with Ambedkar? How can he, a 20th century rationalist, become a prophet?
Well, the conditions are right for him to be elevated to prophethood – despite the fact that what Dalits are doing to him would be the very antithesis of what he himself advocated: use of rational thought, use of constitutional methods of protest, avoidance of superstition and the cult of personality.
In 1949, in a speech to the constituent assembly, he clearly said that “hero worship is a sure road to degradation and eventual dictatorship.” But that will not stop Dalits from doing that to him, for their need for Ambedkar overpowers what he actually stood for.
Let’s briefly discuss the conditions as they exist now.
One, Dalits, despite all their own internal divisions, are the largest single disadvantaged group in India and they constitute the biggest voting chuck – if we take them together. The attempt to raise Ambedkar to god-like status is important to consolidate the power of this vote base and demand a greater share of the national resources and wealth.
Two, there is little doubt that Dalit alienation is high – and Hindu self-doubt is peaking right now. Dalits need a towering icon like Ambedkar – no Dalit in the past or in the present has thought so deeply about society as Ambedkar – to give themselves a sense of superiority over the rest of society. We all know Ambedkar was only human, and he would have made his share of mistakes, but admitting this does not serve the Dalit purpose of consolidating power.
Muslims who lived in the era of the prophet knew he was only human and made his share of errors, but after him his followers saw the need to place him beyond human doubt to consolidate their political power. The same thing happened in early Christianity when Paul delinked the historical Jesus from the Jesus who was required for political and societal consolidation.
Ambedkar’s tryst with prophethood has clearly begun. In due course, he will be up there with the Buddha as the most important prophet of the Dalits. Never mind if he isn’t the Ambedkar we know from his writings.
Falsification of truth and the mythification of historical personalities is vital for power.
http://www.firstpost.com/india/toon-trouble-why-dalits-prefer-the-ambedkar-myth-to-reality-307063.html
Yes, he’s right. The conditions for converting Ambedkar from just an extraordinary human being and social reformer to prophet seem just right.
Several conditions must exist for a social or political icon to be elevated to the status of near-god or prophet. Four, in particular, are important.
First, the political conditions must be right. There must be sufficiently large numbers that feel excluded and are in search of the right way to empower themselves.
Second, the sense of alienation from the dominant culture must be acute and widely felt across the community. If the dominant culture somehow conveys the impression of superiority, the task of elevating a leader to saint becomes easier.
Third, the dominant culture should be in decline and seized with self-doubt.
Fourth, elevation to prophethood does not depend on what the prophet may actually have said or done; it depends on the will of his followers and their need for political power.
Let’s consider the historical precedents first. Buddha and Mahavira emerged as non-theistic icons and prophets when overweening Brahminism was creating a social decline and sense of disgust in the broader population.
The elevation of Jesus Christ to Son of God happened centuries after the crucifixion and that, too, not among the people he was born – the Jews, where he would merely have been a social reformer. Jesus became messiah first in Europe, where the decline of Roman values was becoming apparent and anti-Semitism was rising as a political mood.
The rise of the prophet of Islam happened in the context where both Jews and Christians claimed to be people of the book, and hence superior. They looked down on the tribal Arabs as uncultured and uncivilised. Mohammed emerged as a prophet in this backdrop.
A counter-point can be made with Gandhi. As moral leaders go, Gandhi would have been considered a prophet or saint equivalent to a Jesus or Mohammed in any other era but the 20th century. But the 20th century was the era of rising rationalism, where saints had to be reduced to ordinary mortals. The demythification of Gandhi has begun in the west, and will continue.
So why should it be any different with Ambedkar? How can he, a 20th century rationalist, become a prophet?
Well, the conditions are right for him to be elevated to prophethood – despite the fact that what Dalits are doing to him would be the very antithesis of what he himself advocated: use of rational thought, use of constitutional methods of protest, avoidance of superstition and the cult of personality.
In 1949, in a speech to the constituent assembly, he clearly said that “hero worship is a sure road to degradation and eventual dictatorship.” But that will not stop Dalits from doing that to him, for their need for Ambedkar overpowers what he actually stood for.
Let’s briefly discuss the conditions as they exist now.
One, Dalits, despite all their own internal divisions, are the largest single disadvantaged group in India and they constitute the biggest voting chuck – if we take them together. The attempt to raise Ambedkar to god-like status is important to consolidate the power of this vote base and demand a greater share of the national resources and wealth.
Two, there is little doubt that Dalit alienation is high – and Hindu self-doubt is peaking right now. Dalits need a towering icon like Ambedkar – no Dalit in the past or in the present has thought so deeply about society as Ambedkar – to give themselves a sense of superiority over the rest of society. We all know Ambedkar was only human, and he would have made his share of mistakes, but admitting this does not serve the Dalit purpose of consolidating power.
Muslims who lived in the era of the prophet knew he was only human and made his share of errors, but after him his followers saw the need to place him beyond human doubt to consolidate their political power. The same thing happened in early Christianity when Paul delinked the historical Jesus from the Jesus who was required for political and societal consolidation.
Ambedkar’s tryst with prophethood has clearly begun. In due course, he will be up there with the Buddha as the most important prophet of the Dalits. Never mind if he isn’t the Ambedkar we know from his writings.
Falsification of truth and the mythification of historical personalities is vital for power.
http://www.firstpost.com/india/toon-trouble-why-dalits-prefer-the-ambedkar-myth-to-reality-307063.html
MulaiAzhagi- Posts : 1254
Join date : 2011-12-20
Similar topics» This is what loneliness does to human beings
» Inbred human beings too need to be fed to the lions
» Are Indian men the most uncivilized human beings in the world?
» At last human rights violations in Indian occupied Tamil Nadu discussed at United Nations Human Rights Council
» Human Rights for a vile human!
» Inbred human beings too need to be fed to the lions
» Are Indian men the most uncivilized human beings in the world?
» At last human rights violations in Indian occupied Tamil Nadu discussed at United Nations Human Rights Council
» Human Rights for a vile human!
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum