Marathadi-Saamiyaar wrote:

Jebediah Mburuburu wrote:
 
everywhere in india, however, the root cause of the problem of squalor is hinduism.

A memory and knowledge test for Jebi Achachan:

Name the country and people's religion in these photos

Holy photo exhibit - A

Holy Photo Exihibot - B

southindian wrote:

Marathadi-Saamiyaar wrote:

Jebediah Mburuburu wrote:
 
everywhere in india, however, the root cause of the problem of squalor is hinduism.

A memory and knowledge test for Jebi Achachan:

Name the country and people's religion in these photos

Holy photo exhibit - A

Holy Photo Exihibot - B

The first can be from any city in UP, India and second from any city next to the shore from Bihar, India

MaxEntropy_Man wrote:

Marathadi-Saamiyaar wrote:

Jebediah Mburuburu wrote:
 
everywhere in india, however, the root cause of the problem of squalor is hinduism.

MAX:

What is your view of Jebi Achachan's opinion?

i certainly don't think hinduism is the root cause of all the squalor. however, it is difficult to argue that setting afloat burning or half-burnt corpses on the river is anything but a hindu practice. why do they do it? i find it disgusting. what is the origin of this practice?

MaxEntropy_Man wrote:

southindian wrote:

Marathadi-Saamiyaar wrote:

Jebediah Mburuburu wrote:
 
everywhere in india, however, the root cause of the problem of squalor is hinduism.

A memory and knowledge test for Jebi Achachan:

Name the country and people's religion in these photos

Holy photo exhibit - A

Holy Photo Exihibot - B

The first can be from any city in UP, India and second from any city next to the shore from Bihar, India

UP has cities?

southindian wrote:

MaxEntropy_Man wrote:

southindian wrote:

Marathadi-Saamiyaar wrote:

Jebediah Mburuburu wrote:
 
everywhere in india, however, the root cause of the problem of squalor is hinduism.

A memory and knowledge test for Jebi Achachan:

Name the country and people's religion in these photos

Holy photo exhibit - A

Holy Photo Exihibot - B

The first can be from any city in UP, India and second from any city next to the shore from Bihar, India

UP has cities?

Which ones you visited?

Jebediah Mburuburu wrote:

there is no filth, deprivation, or human misery in the world (or in india) on the scale and intensity seen in the photographs posted in the article linked. if you disagree, show me some photographs of other places and people as evidence. the photographs of jakarta and manila shown in the same article don't compare; it's mostly of garbage, not shit or decaying dead bodies.
 
the reason why the boys in the photgraphs of india are diving into a cesspool of stagnant shit to search for valuables is that they can't make a living any other way; and that's because they belong to a low caste, according to the ancient wisdom of the hindus. this is a hindu problem. if you disagree, show me photographs of muslims or christians living lives that are as squalid or more so than the ones depicted in the photographs in the article.
 
squalor is a problem in other parts of india also, but not to the extent it is in northindia. one reason for that might be that the northindians are engaged in activities that have negative or zero economic value to themselves and others, for example, language, caste, and religious wars. if you disagree, you are welcome to present evidence that that is not the case.
 
everywhere in india, however, the root cause of the problem of squalor is hinduism.

MaxEntropy_Man wrote:

southindian wrote:

MaxEntropy_Man wrote:

southindian wrote:

Marathadi-Saamiyaar wrote:

A memory and knowledge test for Jebi Achachan:

Name the country and people's religion in these photos

Holy photo exhibit - A

Holy Photo Exihibot - B

The first can be from any city in UP, India and second from any city next to the shore from Bihar, India

UP has cities?

Which ones you visited?

lucknow, meerut, dehradun, and muzaffarnagar none of which i found fit the description of a city.

MaxEntropy_Man wrote:

lucknow, meerut, dehradun, and muzaffarnagar none of which i found fit the description of a city.

Jebediah Mburuburu wrote:

Merlot Daruwala wrote:Haha..Unkil, which is your country? Also, did the Muslims, Christians and other non-Hindus stop shitting altogether?

 
"Haha..,  " "Unkil, which is your country?"  -- mrs menon.
 
experiencing difficulty comprehending a simple english sentence, auNTtie??
 
"did the Muslims, Christians and other non-Hindus stop shitting altogether?" -- mrs menon.
 
do you ask that q because you think that the ganges is a holy river for muslims and christians, and 100 million of them flock to the confluence of the ganges and the yamuna to shit on india and in the ganges, then bathe in it, and set their dead relatives afloat on the river? is that what you understood from the article linked, mrs menon?
 
moreover, auNTtie-ji, there's not a great deal of data on muslims' and christians' defecatory habits; their shit is not out there for all to see, as hindu shit is, in the rivers, ponds, lakes, beaches, fields, mountains, valleys, streets, nooks, and crannies of india.

Idéfix wrote:
Jebji, why does it upset and anger you when Merlot calls you unkil? Also, does the lack of data on the defecatory habits of Muslims and Christians make their shit disappear?

confuzzled dude wrote:

While the sanitary situation in India is nothing to be proud of, incessant badgering of North India/Hindus only proves how out of touch you have been with reality; your personal biases seem to preclude you from looking at the facts rationally. Please do take a look at the link below

In Pictures: The World's 25 Dirtiest Cities

Seva Lamberdar wrote:

MaxEntropy_Man wrote:

Marathadi-Saamiyaar wrote:

Jebediah Mburuburu wrote:
 
everywhere in india, however, the root cause of the problem of squalor is hinduism.

MAX:

What is your view of Jebi Achachan's opinion?

i certainly don't think hinduism is the root cause of all the squalor. however, it is difficult to argue that setting afloat burning or half-burnt corpses on the river is anything but a hindu practice. why do they do it? i find it disgusting. what is the origin of this practice?

If you lead the campaign to clean the Ganges, I will tell you the origin of this practice.
Deal, or no deal?

MaxEntropy_Man wrote:

Seva Lamberdar wrote:

MaxEntropy_Man wrote:

Marathadi-Saamiyaar wrote:

Jebediah Mburuburu wrote:
 
everywhere in india, however, the root cause of the problem of squalor is hinduism.

MAX:

What is your view of Jebi Achachan's opinion?

i certainly don't think hinduism is the root cause of all the squalor. however, it is difficult to argue that setting afloat burning or half-burnt corpses on the river is anything but a hindu practice. why do they do it? i find it disgusting. what is the origin of this practice?

If you lead the campaign to clean the Ganges, I will tell you the origin of this practice.
Deal, or no deal?

you obviously believe that the problems of the ganges are not primarily caused by human behavior and that they cannot be addressed by a change in human behavior. why do you believe this to be the case?

Seva Lamberdar wrote:

If you think that is the case, then you should prepare an action plan (for cleaning the Ganges) to prove me wrong. We can discuss the merits and demerits of that plan at that stage.

MaxEntropy_Man wrote:

Seva Lamberdar wrote:

If you think that is the case, then you should prepare an action plan (for cleaning the Ganges) to prove me wrong. We can discuss the merits and demerits of that plan at that stage.

i asked you a simple question and i was hoping for a straight answer, not your usual obfuscation. let me repeat the question: do you or do you not believe that human behavior, not poor technology is responsible for the mess that the ganges is?

Rashmun wrote:

is the damage irreversible? Considering that this is running water once we figure out how to treat the sewage water effectively before discharging it into the river and also ensure that bodies are cremated before immersion will not the problem not get solved?

nenu wrote:

Rashmun wrote:

is the damage irreversible? Considering that this is running water once we figure out how to treat the sewage water effectively before discharging it into the river and also ensure that bodies are cremated before immersion will not the problem not get solved?

From what I heard, this problem is almost solved. No half burned bodies are thrown into the river. You don't find any half burned dead bodies in the river like before. It's made sure that only fully burned ashes are immersed into the river. So anyone crying that the pollution is caused by the hindu practice don't know what they are talking. The pollution seems to be mostly from industrial waste and sewage. That needs to be addressed.

truthbetold wrote:Jm's fascination with Hindu shit blinds him to facts. Indian cities and their associated poverty and squalor were phenomena of the past 2 to 3 hundred years. The rulers in that period are British who neglected living conditions of people in their colonies.
Native rulers cannot be absolved of all blame since 1947 but Rome is not built in a day.
criticism of ganga is well deserved and Hindus should be ashamed of their prestigious river is a cesspool. But jm's criticism is not genuine and is not intended to motivate positive action.
Jm's verbal vomits are a way to denigrate Hinduism in one form or other. Facts can be misused to make bigoted remarks to satisfy personal agenda.

Rishi wrote:

truthbetold wrote:Jm's fascination with Hindu shit blinds him to facts. Indian cities and their associated poverty and squalor were phenomena of the past 2 to 3 hundred years. The rulers in that period are British who neglected living conditions of people in their colonies.
Native rulers cannot be absolved of all blame since 1947 but Rome is not built in a day.
criticism of ganga is well deserved and Hindus should be ashamed of their prestigious river is a cesspool. But jm's criticism is not genuine and is not intended to motivate positive action.
Jm's verbal vomits are a way to denigrate Hinduism in one form or other. Facts can be misused to make bigoted remarks to satisfy personal agenda.

Touche.

truthbetold wrote:

Rishi wrote:

truthbetold wrote:Jm's fascination with Hindu shit blinds him to facts. Indian cities and their associated poverty and squalor were phenomena of the past 2 to 3 hundred years. The rulers in that period are British who neglected living conditions of people in their colonies.
Native rulers cannot be absolved of all blame since 1947 but Rome is not built in a day.
criticism of ganga is well deserved and Hindus should be ashamed of their prestigious river is a cesspool. But jm's criticism is not genuine and is not intended to motivate positive action.
Jm's verbal vomits are a way to denigrate Hinduism in one form or other. Facts can be misused to make bigoted remarks to satisfy personal agenda.

Touche.

Yes. You are. Loyalty to servile servants of crammer.

truthbetold wrote:

Rishi wrote:

truthbetold wrote:Jm's fascination with Hindu shit blinds him to facts. Indian cities and their associated poverty and squalor were phenomena of the past 2 to 3 hundred years. The rulers in that period are British who neglected living conditions of people in their colonies.
Native rulers cannot be absolved of all blame since 1947 but Rome is not built in a day.
criticism of ganga is well deserved and Hindus should be ashamed of their prestigious river is a cesspool. But jm's criticism is not genuine and is not intended to motivate positive action.
Jm's verbal vomits are a way to denigrate Hinduism in one form or other. Facts can be misused to make bigoted remarks to satisfy personal agenda.

Touche.

Yes. You are. Loyalty to servile servants of crammer.

truthbetold wrote:Jm's fascination with Hindu shit blinds him to facts. Indian cities and their associated poverty and squalor were phenomena of the past 2 to 3 hundred years. The rulers in that period are British who neglected living conditions of people in their colonies.
Native rulers cannot be absolved of all blame since 1947 but Rome is not built in a day.
criticism of ganga is well deserved and Hindus should be ashamed of their prestigious river is a cesspool. But jm's criticism is not genuine and is not intended to motivate positive action.
Jm's verbal vomits are a way to denigrate Hinduism in one form or other. Facts can be misused to make bigoted remarks to satisfy personal agenda.

truthbetold wrote:

Rishi wrote:
Touche.

Yes. You are. Loyalty to servile servants of crammer.