Justice Katlu should resign

Uppili wrote:Chairman of the (free) Press Council of India writing in Paki Newspaper bad mouthing about CM of an Indian State and against the main opposition.

To call the killings of Muslims as a spontaneous reaction reminds one of Kristallnacht in Germany in November 1938, when the entire Jewish community there was attacked, many killed, their synagogues burnt, shops vandalised, etc. after a German diplomat in Paris was shot by a Jewish youngster whose family had been persecuted by the Nazis. The Nazis claimed that this was a ‘spontaneous’ reaction, but, in fact, it was planned and executed by the authorities using fanatic mobs.

Uppili wrote:Chairman of the (free) Press Council of India writing in Paki Newspaper bad mouthing about CM of an Indian State and against the main opposition.

Hellsangel wrote:

Uppili wrote:Chairman of the (free) Press Council of India writing in Paki Newspaper bad mouthing about CM of an Indian State and against the main opposition.

How stupid is he?

This is the article:

http://tribune.com.pk/story/511944/modi-and-the-2002-massacre/

Godwin's law in effect

To call the killings of Muslims as a spontaneous reaction reminds one of Kristallnacht in Germany in November 1938, when the entire Jewish community there was attacked, many killed, their synagogues burnt, shops vandalised, etc. after a German diplomat in Paris was shot by a Jewish youngster whose family had been persecuted by the Nazis. The Nazis claimed that this was a ‘spontaneous’ reaction, but, in fact, it was planned and executed by the authorities using fanatic mobs.

Rashmun wrote:

Uppili wrote:Chairman of the (free) Press Council of India writing in Paki Newspaper bad mouthing about CM of an Indian State and against the main opposition.

this is the same article that was published in the Hindu. How can anyone stop a Paki newspaper from publishing something published in some other paper. For instance, TOI frequently published articles from NYTimes.

Uppili wrote:

Rashmun wrote:

Uppili wrote:Chairman of the (free) Press Council of India writing in Paki Newspaper bad mouthing about CM of an Indian State and against the main opposition.

this is the same article that was published in the Hindu. How can anyone stop a Paki newspaper from publishing something published in some other paper. For instance, TOI frequently published articles from NYTimes.

Are YOU saying that Justice Katlu - although he is the Chairman of the Press council of India - is correct in writing a partisan article against the major opposition party ?

Rashmun wrote:

Uppili wrote:

Are YOU saying that Justice Katlu - although he is the Chairman of the Press council of India - is correct in writing a partisan article against the major opposition party ?

What you are claiming is not true. His article is not against the BJP.

Uppili wrote:

Rashmun wrote:

Uppili wrote:

Are YOU saying that Justice Katlu - although he is the Chairman of the Press council of India - is correct in writing a partisan article against the major opposition party ?

What you are claiming is not true. His article is not against the BJP.

You did not answer the question - not surprising.

Rashmun wrote:

Uppili wrote:

Rashmun wrote:

Uppili wrote:

Are YOU saying that Justice Katlu - although he is the Chairman of the Press council of India - is correct in writing a partisan article against the major opposition party ?

What you are claiming is not true. His article is not against the BJP.

You did not answer the question - not surprising.

i have pointed out that your question is erroneous. His criticism is not for the BJP--it is confined to Narendra Modi.

panini press wrote:There are some differences between the article published in The Hindu and that in the Pakistani newspaper. Apparently Markji sent in his article to both papers, and each paper edited it somewhat differently.

Markji shows a remarkable lack of judgment in publishing this in the Pakistani paper. He should resign his post and join Congress so he can openly express his political views. I wish him luck as a Congress politician.

panini press wrote:There are some differences between the article published in The Hindu and that in the Pakistani newspaper. Apparently Markji sent in his article to both papers, and each paper edited it somewhat differently.

Markji shows a remarkable lack of judgment in publishing this in the Pakistani paper. He should resign his post and join Congress so he can openly express his political views. I wish him luck as a Congress politician.

goodcitizn wrote:Mark Katju should be kicked out of his quasi-government post by the Center on two counts:

1. Sending an article to a Pakistani publication about crimes committed against muslims in Gujarath as its CM-sponsored occurrence could further inflame Pakistanis against India. This has the appearance of being anti-patriotic.

2. It is reprehensible for a quasi-government employee appointed as the Chairman of the Press Council of India to be shooting his mouth off about his political views (particularly when appointed by the Congress-led Center) accusing the CM of Gujarath, an important figure in the opposition party, of foul play in anti-muslim riots.

Shame on Manmohan Singh, Sonia and the UPA coalition for not taking action against this loose cannon who is only making them look complicit and guilty.

Rashmun wrote:

goodcitizn wrote:Mark Katju should be kicked out of his quasi-government post by the Center on two counts:

1. Sending an article to a Pakistani publication about crimes committed against muslims in Gujarath as its CM-sponsored occurrence could further inflame Pakistanis against India. This has the appearance of being anti-patriotic.

2. It is reprehensible for a quasi-government employee appointed as the Chairman of the Press Council of India to be shooting his mouth off about his political views (particularly when appointed by the Congress-led Center) accusing the CM of Gujarath, an important figure in the opposition party, of foul play in anti-muslim riots.

Shame on Manmohan Singh, Sonia and the UPA coalition for not taking action against this loose cannon who is only making them look complicit and guilty.

Are you a narendra Modi supporter?