Sould the maratha caste get reservations ?

ashdoc wrote:The maratha caste is an influential caste in Maharashtra and does not deserve reservations .

Considering that Marathas have been powerful in Maharashtra since the days of Chhatrapati Shivaji and their economic status is better than most castes , giving them reservations will be making mockery of the quota system .

Marathadi-Saamiyaar wrote:

ashdoc wrote:The maratha caste is an influential caste in Maharashtra and does not deserve reservations .

Considering that Marathas have been powerful in Maharashtra since the days of Chhatrapati Shivaji and their economic status is better than most castes , giving them reservations will be making mockery of the quota system .

If muslims who ruled for a 1000 years and subjected the majority hindu population to Jizzya, rape, forced conversion, killings and looting can be viewed upon as victims and considered for reservations, then any group is indeed deserving of the same consideration.

confuzzled dude wrote:

Marathadi-Saamiyaar wrote:

ashdoc wrote:The maratha caste is an influential caste in Maharashtra and does not deserve reservations .

Considering that Marathas have been powerful in Maharashtra since the days of Chhatrapati Shivaji and their economic status is better than most castes , giving them reservations will be making mockery of the quota system .

If muslims who ruled for a 1000 years and subjected the majority hindu population to Jizzya, rape, forced conversion, killings and looting can be viewed upon as victims and considered for reservations, then any group is indeed deserving of the same consideration.

Let's do this slowly.. Ordinary muslim folks viewed upon as victims these days due to some of the unfortunate incidents occurred in the last 100 years or so (thanks to braindead Chaddi acts). You should educate your fellow Chaddis that these guys were actually Hindus until forcefully converted by barbarians, and preach them not to subject those poor guys to further humiliation.

Marathadi-Saamiyaar wrote:

confuzzled dude wrote:

Marathadi-Saamiyaar wrote:

ashdoc wrote:The maratha caste is an influential caste in Maharashtra and does not deserve reservations .

Considering that Marathas have been powerful in Maharashtra since the days of Chhatrapati Shivaji and their economic status is better than most castes , giving them reservations will be making mockery of the quota system .

If muslims who ruled for a 1000 years and subjected the majority hindu population to Jizzya, rape, forced conversion, killings and looting can be viewed upon as victims and considered for reservations, then any group is indeed deserving of the same consideration.

Let's do this slowly.. Ordinary muslim folks viewed upon as victims these days due to some of the unfortunate incidents occurred in the last 100 years or so (thanks to braindead Chaddi acts). You should educate your fellow Chaddis that these guys were actually Hindus until forcefully converted by barbarians, and preach them not to subject those poor guys to further humiliation.

You are really a top candidate and competing with other front runners for the SuCh PiS 2013 award.

Thank you.... as soon as these "poor guys" acknowledge what you said "we were actually Hindus until forcefully converted by barbarians," the Chaddis will provide an instant solution.

1. since you are focusing about the last 100 years (or just 40 years before 1950), how about stating here  the "rationale" behind the reservation (please feel free to Google).  
2. Also, who was ruling India over the last 60 years during which these "poor guys" were victimized.  why did not they take any action to solve this issue.
3. By your 100 yr statement are you saying that the Government that ruled India for most part in the last 60 years is indeed responsible for victimizing these Poor guys?"  

confuzzled dude wrote:

Marathadi-Saamiyaar wrote:

confuzzled dude wrote:

Marathadi-Saamiyaar wrote:

ashdoc wrote:The maratha caste is an influential caste in Maharashtra and does not deserve reservations .

Considering that Marathas have been powerful in Maharashtra since the days of Chhatrapati Shivaji and their economic status is better than most castes , giving them reservations will be making mockery of the quota system .

If muslims who ruled for a 1000 years and subjected the majority hindu population to Jizzya, rape, forced conversion, killings and looting can be viewed upon as victims and considered for reservations, then any group is indeed deserving of the same consideration.

Let's do this slowly.. Ordinary muslim folks viewed upon as victims these days due to some of the unfortunate incidents occurred in the last 100 years or so (thanks to braindead Chaddi acts). You should educate your fellow Chaddis that these guys were actually Hindus until forcefully converted by barbarians, and preach them not to subject those poor guys to further humiliation.

You are really a top candidate and competing with other front runners for the SuCh PiS 2013 award.

Thank you.... as soon as these "poor guys" acknowledge what you said "we were actually Hindus until forcefully converted by barbarians," the Chaddis will provide an instant solution.

1. since you are focusing about the last 100 years (or just 40 years before 1950), how about stating here  the "rationale" behind the reservation (please feel free to Google).  
2. Also, who was ruling India over the last 60 years during which these "poor guys" were victimized.  why did not they take any action to solve this issue.
3. By your 100 yr statement are you saying that the Government that ruled India for most part in the last 60 years is indeed responsible for victimizing these Poor guys?"  

You see they are only following Hindu err.. their erstwhile religion's tradition when it comes to reservations. All your arguments about victimization, govt's inaction apply to scheduled castes too.